Why challengers will keep coming
Scott Bagby ·
Technology and changing audiences keep creating openings for new sports properties. Established leagues can remain successful while those opportunities grow.
A fan can love Drive to Survive, follow the drivers and jump at an invitation to Formula 1’s Paddock Club, yet have little interest in watching an entire Grand Prix or buying a general admission ticket.
There is no contradiction. The personalities, access and social experience might be precisely what that person values. They do not have to become a regular race viewer for their interest to count.
That distinction matters when thinking about where the next generation of sports properties will come from. Audiences want different things, and technology keeps expanding the ways to serve them. Established properties have considerable advantages, but they also have businesses to protect.
Challengers will keep forming around that gap. Some will fail. Their failure will not remove the forces that brought them into existence.
Available does not mean suitable
An offering can work well for one audience and poorly for another. A game scheduled for an evening audience in North America may fall in the middle of the night in Europe. A ticket affordable to a corporate executive may be out of reach for someone early in their career. A broadcast accessible on a phone may still be designed around a large television screen.
Making something available does not mean it suits the person trying to enjoy it.
But correcting one mismatch does not necessarily create an attractive alternative. A European NBA fan may want to watch particular players competing at the highest level. Another basketball game in a convenient time zone cannot automatically provide that.
The opportunity requires a deeper understanding of what people value. Competition and sporting excellence matter, alongside personalities, storytelling, atmosphere, participation and the occasion itself. Their importance varies between people and within the same person’s life.
Properties should take those preferences seriously on their own terms. Someone who enjoys occasional clips need not be treated as an incomplete customer whose real value will arrive once they watch full games.
Freedom to build differently
A challenger can make choices around an audience from the outset: the format, schedule, production, distribution, live experience and commercial partnerships.
TGL illustrates what that can look like. Its inaugural offering combined approximately two-hour prime-time matches with a shot clock, microphones on players and a purpose-built venue. Technology helped shape the competition and the experience together. Developed in partnership with the PGA Tour, it also shows that new properties can emerge through cooperation with established organisations.
Those choices do not establish that a business will endure. They demonstrate the scope to create a different proposition.
Simply offering a smaller version of an incumbent can expose everything the newcomer lacks: history, established loyalties, talent and significance. A challenger needs reasons for people to care about its own experience.
Its freedom becomes valuable when the choices reinforce one another around an identifiable audience.
The business an incumbent already has
Established properties can recognise these opportunities perfectly well. Pursuing them involves a different calculation.
Consider a cheaper, more flexible viewing offer. It might attract people who currently spend nothing. It might also encourage existing customers to spend less or reduce the value of a broadcaster’s exclusivity. The additional revenue has to be weighed against the business exposed to risk.
This tension is explicit in Liberty Media’s annual report. It explains that Formula 1 and MotoGP can operate across platforms, while warning that developments online may affect existing licensing economics. Failing to adapt to changing viewing habits also carries risks to media-rights and sponsorship value.
There is no universal answer to that trade-off. Protecting established revenue can be sensible. It can also allow someone else to build audience relationships that become valuable later.
Contractual restrictions may have an expiry date. The economic dilemma can survive it. Recovering the freedom to act does not necessarily make acting attractive.
An opportunity can therefore be worth pursuing for a challenger and rational to leave alone for an incumbent. Previous generations of commercially sound decisions can help explain that difference.
A worthwhile business need not replace a league
A challenger does not need to threaten an incumbent’s entire business for its opportunity to matter. It needs an audience that values its proposition enough to sustain it.
How large that audience must be depends on what the property intends to build. A focused series of events and a global league with expensive talent have different requirements. Audience spending, frequency of participation and partner value matter alongside headcount.
I saw at Skype how a new proposition could change the terms of competition while established operators continued to participate. Skype’s public filing described both its substantial international calling reach and partnerships with operators including Verizon Wireless and KDDI. Disruption involved new relationships as well as competitive pressure.
Sport should expect similarly varied outcomes: independent challengers, partnerships, adaptations by incumbents and failures. Established leaders can remain strong throughout substantial industry change.
More challengers are good for sport
Technology will continue to expand what properties can offer. Audience preferences will continue to evolve. Existing businesses will continue to face choices about which opportunities justify the consequences of pursuing them.
That is why challengers will keep coming, even after some fail.
This is good for sport. Continued entry creates opportunities to test different formats, experiences and ways to participate. Successful experiments can serve audiences differently, create new commercial activity and give established properties reasons to improve.
Individual failures can impose serious costs on athletes, employees and partners. Enthusiasm for experimentation must sit alongside careful judgement about each business.
For venues, production companies, distributors, sponsors and other ecosystem players, this means a continuing flow of potential customers and partners. They do not need every challenger to become the next major league. They need to understand which properties offer something worthwhile and can deliver on their commitments.
The failure of one challenger does not close the opportunity. The next will still come—and sport benefits from people continuing to try.