DAOKO

The sport is the easy part

Scott Bagby ·

In September, LIV Golf filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy after Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund ended its funding. Nine months earlier, Grand Slam Track did the same, owing athletes and vendors between $10 million and $50 million. Both had stars. Both had money. Neither built a business that could stand on its own.

Over the same period, Unrivaled grew revenue from an estimated $27 million to $45 million in its second season and raised money at a $650 million valuation. The PWHL drew more than 1.1 million fans in its third regular season.

New sports properties can work, and more are coming. That is an opportunity for investors, venues, brands and partners. It is also a risk. In my experience, the sport is the easy part. New properties fail on the business around it, usually because capital is committed against commercial assumptions that don't survive contact with the market. The investors and partners who test those assumptions early, and help close the gaps, will back the right ones.

1

An opening is only the beginning

Challenger properties will keep coming, even after some fail. As I explore in Why challengers will keep coming, technology and changing audience preferences create opportunities that established properties have different economic reasons to pursue—or leave alone. A newcomer can build a worthwhile business without displacing an established league. That continued experimentation is good for sport and creates opportunities for investors, venues and commercial partners.

But freedom to design a proposition does not establish the ability to deliver it. A challenger still needs credible revenue assumptions, the capabilities and partnerships to execute, and funding that matches its ambitions and timetable. Those are the foundations investors and partners need to examine. My experience at Project B showed how quickly the sporting proposition could come together—and how much harder the commercial business could be to build.

2

Where the assumptions break

I spent two years as Head of Commercial at Project B, a global basketball Grand Prix circuit that has not yet launched. The basketball came together quickly. Star players signed. The commercial machine was harder, in three places.

Ticketing and data. Owning our fan data mattered, so we wanted one global ticketing partner. Technical integration was straightforward at every venue. The contracts were the problem. Of the eight venues we negotiated with, only one would let us bring our own ticketing partner. Everywhere else we had to work through the venue's existing provider, and none of them would share data with us.

Sponsorship. Our plan assumed deals would close within a few months of star players signing. In practice, the market norm is around 18 months, because we were unproven and had no data from previous seasons.

Partners. I saw one partnership consume more than six months and significant spend before we changed course. We didn't have the in-house expertise to test it properly at the start.

None of this is unusual. Venues hold exclusive deals for ticketing, food and beverage, merchandise and sponsorship because those deals pay. An unproven property asking a venue to set them aside is asking it to take a risk. Brands price uncertainty. A clean slate gives a new property flexibility. It doesn't make the commercial machine any cheaper or faster to build.

3

Capital allocation is the real test

LIV and Grand Slam Track show what happens when capital stands in for a commercial engine. LIV received close to $6 billion in Saudi funding over five years. When the funding stopped, nothing underneath could carry the business. Grand Slam Track launched claiming a $30 million bankroll and struggled to pay athletes once committed funding fell through.

The properties that are working have been deliberate about what they build and what they borrow. The PWHL appointed Oak View Group as its exclusive sponsorship sales partner. TGL was set up in partnership with the PGA Tour, plays in its own purpose-built venue and has just extended its ESPN deal. The PWHL also planned conservatively. Its initial projection was 1,000 fans a game. This season it averaged more than 9,000.

For anyone putting money in, the lesson is simple. The outcome depends far more on whether the commercial assumptions are accurate, and whether spending matches them, than on the quality of the sport.

4

How to vet a new property, then help it

Investment diligence usually covers the financials, the legal structure and the sporting concept. Fewer investors test the commercial and operating plan with the same rigour, and that is where most of the risk sits. I'd approach it in three stages.

1. Assess before investing. Test every revenue line and the evidence behind it. How long will sponsorship take to close, and at what price for an unproven property? What will venues allow, given the deals they already have? Who will own the ticketing data? Which cost lines are missing? Does management include people who have built this machine before? Then run the downside case, with sponsorship arriving 18 months late at half the price.

2. Build the plan. Turn the investment case into a commercial roadmap, a budget and a timetable. Choose partners deliberately, name decision owners, and sequence commitments so an early wrong call doesn't consume the capital needed later.

3. Support execution where asked. Some properties will want experienced help with specific workstreams such as sponsorship, ticketing, distribution or hospitality. Management should keep ownership of its business and choose the support it needs.

One rule applies at every stage. Whoever assesses a property should not be quietly bidding for its delivery work. Separate the two, or disclose the interest.

Venues can apply the same discipline. New properties will keep asking for dates, and each one will be different. A venue that judges each on its own business plan, and has a standard way to say yes to the strong ones, will win business its competitors turn away.

5

The difference shows up early

Challenger properties will keep coming, and that is good for sport. For investors, venues and commercial partners, the task is to assess each on its own merits: the audience it intends to serve, the business it wants to build and the evidence behind its plans.

A compelling sporting proposition earns attention. Confidence comes from testing the commercial assumptions, understanding the dependencies and matching commitments to realistic revenues and timelines. Doing that early can reveal weaknesses while there is still time to address them—and give promising properties a stronger foundation.

The opportunity is to recognise which challengers have credible foundations and help them turn that potential into a business that lasts.

Contact

If you’re working through one of these questions, I’d be glad to compare notes.

scott@daoko.com