Built to last, designed to change
Scott Bagby ·
A venue is built for 30 years or more. The way fans follow sport now changes every few years. Most venues are still planned around the configuration on opening day, and the gap shows up within a year or two of opening.
Fans follow sport in moments and in parallel, and the stream carries the picture everywhere. What it cannot carry is the gathering. That gives the venue three jobs. It has to be the best place to live the moment. It has to be the place the moment is made and shared from. And it has to carry the atmosphere beyond its walls, to the fan zone, the watch party and the district, including on days when there is no game.
The practical approach is to separate decisions by how fast they will need to change. The structure should last. The spaces inside it should be cheap to change. The technology, programming and rights terms should be expected to change every few years. Most of the value is decided at feasibility, before a project is public.
1. The problem: venues are planned years before they open
A venue brief is often written many years before the first event. By opening day, the assumptions behind it are already old.
What the evidence shows
- Hong Kong's Kai Tak Sports Park opened in March 2025. In its first year the stadium and arena ran at close to 90% utilisation, and the stadium drew more than 1.8 million attendees (Kai Tak Sports Park).
- It still fell short of the sports event-day targets set in a 2019 government document. The culture, sports and tourism secretary said sport and concert demand had differed from earlier projections. Concerts were booked back to back and the retail space was more than 90% leased (The Standard).
- Philadelphia shows the expensive version. The Flyers' and 76ers' arena opened in 1996 and finished a $400 million renovation in 2024. A replacement arena is still planned for the 2031–32 season (AP via ESPN).
- Industry operators say big-league venue lifespans are shrinking well below the customary 30 years (VenuesNow).
My view
- Kai Tak is a success story with a lesson inside it. The building worked because it could take what the market wanted in 2025, which was not exactly what the plan expected in 2019.
- That gap will open on every project. The question is whether the building can absorb it cheaply, or whether it needs a renovation to catch up.
2. How fans follow sport now
Live sport still leads. Around it, fans now follow in short moments, through athletes, with other people, and often from outside the building. Fans used to follow teams; now they follow storylines, and the story extends beyond the score. Younger fans come for the occasion as much as the game.
What the evidence shows
- In a 2026 USC Annenberg study of 2,154 US Gen Z adults, 78% said they attend live sport, or would, for celebrities, performances or brand activations rather than purely the game. Half said lower ticket prices would do most to get them to more events. A quarter would rather follow an athlete's story than their games (TheWrap).
- A WSC Sports survey of 1,050 US fans in October 2025 found full live games still rank first overall. For Gen Z, short highlights now rival live games. WSC sells highlights technology, so its interest is worth noting (WSC Sports).
- Inside the venue, Deloitte found 82% of fans use their phones at live events and about a quarter post to social media. Nearly 40% said poor connectivity stopped them using their phone as they wanted. At the same time, 68% said people are on their devices too much (Deloitte). The survey was fielded in March 2023.
My view
- Social use and live attendance happen together. The phone is part of how fans experience the game, and the 68% figure shows they also want the moment to feel worth putting the phone down for.
- Multi-platform viewing has helped bring sports into everyday life. The influencer is now a part of the product. They have a role inside the product and inside the arena. Their needs have to be accommodated for.
3. Job one: the best place to live the moment
If fans can watch anywhere, the venue has to offer what a screen cannot. That is the atmosphere, the people around you and a moment you can say you were at. Atmosphere can be designed in from the start.
What the evidence shows
- Younger fans say a unique, memorable experience is what they want most from a live game. In PwC's survey of about 2,000 US fans, 62% of younger fans said so, significantly more than older fans (PwC). The survey dates from 2024.
- The Clippers' Intuit Dome, a privately funded $1.8 billion arena, built atmosphere into its structure. "The Wall" is 51 uninterrupted rows behind one basket, about 4,500 seats, with no suites breaking it up. The first 13 rows are for vetted home fans who stand all game (ESPN; AECOM).
- The design team studied college student sections, and Borussia Dortmund visited during the design process (ESPN).
My view
- The crowd is part of the product. It is what the fan at home is missing, what the premium guest is paying to be near, and what the camera shows.
- Atmosphere is a structural decision. Rake, sightlines, standing areas and where premium sits are set at feasibility. They are very hard to change later.
- For new leagues and touring events, this matters even more. A half-full bowl looks worse on a stream than it feels in the building. Right-sizing, and the ability to close sections cleanly, protects the product.
- Revenue and atmosphere pull in opposite directions. More premium raises income per seat but thins the crowd that premium guests are paying to be near. The right balance should be set at feasibility, then protected in the structure. Discussed more in point 6 below.
4. Job two: the place moments are made and shared
Every venue is now a broadcast origin. Thousands of fans publish from their seats, and creators are becoming a planned part of the event. The network, the access and the rights all have to be built for sending as much as receiving.
What the evidence shows
- At the 2026 World Cup final, Verizon carried 29.2TB of data in the stadium. Uplink traffic rose nearly 70% during the halftime show as fans shared photos and video. Verizon had expanded capacity at every US host stadium by three to five times (TelecomLead).
- At Game 7 of the 2025 World Series in Toronto, fans used nearly 7.5TB at Rogers Centre, and about 40% of it was uploaded (MobileSyrup).
- The USTA credentialed about 50 social media creators as media for the first time at the 2025 US Open, and described a "creator playground" on the grounds (Reuters via WDEZ). In 2026 it approved close to 100, and paid about two dozen more to make content for the tournament (Front Office Sports).
- The NFL says a creator event in London the day before a game drew more than 60 million views online. The game itself drew six million live views on the NFL's YouTube channel (Digiday).
- Creator spaces so far are event-based. The NFL ran a dedicated "Creator Row" at the Pro Bowl (Forbes). I have not found a verified example of a permanent, purpose-built creator studio inside a venue.
My view
- Connectivity should be specified for peak upload. The busiest moment for the network is the moment the venue is most valuable.
- Creator access is mostly a rights and operations question. Who can film, where, what can be posted, whose sponsors can appear, and who approves it. These terms belong in tenant and event agreements.
- Because creator formats change fast, I would not build a fixed creator studio. I would design adaptable space near the action with power, data, light and sound, and let the use change.
- At Project B, I worked on host broadcast and production and on the YouTube Partner Program. The broadcast clauses in our venue agreements were traditional. They granted the right to film and broadcast, sometimes for a fee, and assumed a single feed. Nobody had planned for hundreds of creators with their own feeds. Rights holders and venues should update these clauses now, and each should decide in advance what it wants and what it will not allow.
5. Job three: beyond the walls and beyond event day
The stream reaches every fan, yet people still want to watch together, close to the event. On the biggest days, much of the live audience gathers near the venue rather than in it. The days with no game matter as much as the days with one. A venue brief now has to cover the district, the fan zone and the screen across town.
What the evidence shows
- During the 13 World Cup matches in Toronto and Vancouver, Rogers customers used 510TB across the stadiums, watch parties and fan zones. That compares with 11TB and 7.4TB for Taylor Swift's Eras Tour shows in the same two cities (MobileSyrup). Bell carried a further 80TB at official fan festivals and municipal fan zones alone (MobileSyrup).
- Cosm runs shared-reality venues of about 700 seats with 87-foot LED domes. The NBA has extended its partnership through 2030, the NFL has signed a deal, and new venues are planned in Atlanta, Detroit and Cleveland in 2026 and 2027 (SVG; MarketScale). Its licensing deals mix fixed fees and revenue shares, and tickets can exceed $200 (Front Office Sports).
- Kai Tak's mall drew more than 7 million visitors in the park's first year. About 30 of its 80 restaurants extend their hours after major events (The Standard).
- Tottenham Hotspur Stadium's dividing pitch slides away in about 25 minutes to reveal an artificial surface. That lets it host at least two NFL games a season, plus concerts and other events, without damaging the grass (Mace).
My view
- The fan zone and the watch party are part of the event's capacity. They need power, data, screening rights and a clear split of income and cost, planned with the venue.
- Shared-reality venues are a new kind of tenant and a new kind of competitor. For a team or league, they are more inventory to sell. For a venue owner, they are a second room for the same moment.
- Non-event days are where a 30-year asset earns its keep between the big nights. That decision sits at master-planning, long before the bowl is drawn.
6. The open question: premium versus the crowd
Premium is now central to venue economics, and I expect that to continue. It also pulls against the fans who create the atmosphere and the content. I do not think the industry has resolved this yet, and I think it should be decided deliberately at feasibility.
What the evidence shows
- Live Nation targets up to 30% premium capacity in new arenas and 25% in retrofits (Q1 2026 earnings call). Sports executives surveyed by PwC in 2026 expect a widening gap between premium and non-premium properties (PwC).
- Courtside seating at the US Open is growing 66% to around 5,000 seats. New and renovated venues have been replacing general seating with premium since the early 1990s. Buffalo's new NFL stadium has fewer seats than its predecessor, and Florida State cut 12,000 seats in favour of suites and clubs (CNN).
- At the 2026 US Open, the average ticket for the first day of competition was $296, up from $250 a year earlier. Several current and former players said they welcome the creators and celebrities, but worry that regular fans are being priced out (Front Office Sports).
- Half of Gen Z in the USC study said lower prices would do most to get them to more live events (TheWrap).
My view
- Every seat is a choice between two goals. Maximising revenue means more premium, higher prices and fewer, wealthier fans. Maximising atmosphere means a larger, louder and more affordable crowd. Push too far towards revenue and the venue sells proximity to an atmosphere it is shrinking. Push too far towards atmosphere and it leaves money on the table in a good year. The balance should be set deliberately at feasibility, then protected in the structure.
- The general fan also makes much of the content that markets the venue for free. Pricing them out has a cost that does not show up on the premium line.
- Premium demand is concentrated among corporate and high-income buyers, and it is cyclical. Capacity should be planned against a downside year, not the best year on record.
- Intuit Dome shows one answer. Protect a large, affordable, loud section in the structure, and put premium where it benefits from that energy.
What would settle it
Operators hold the data to test this. Does premium sell-through or pricing hold up better in venues with a strong general crowd? How much social content comes from general sections versus premium? How did premium renewals behave in the last downturn? I would want those answers before fixing the premium share of any new building.
7. Three clocks
The practical answer is to sort every decision by how fast it will need to change. Architects call this pace layering, after Stewart Brand's How Buildings Learn. The commercial forces above map onto it cleanly.
| Clock | Lasts | What sits on it | Decide at feasibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | 30+ years | Bowl, rake, roof, core, structural allowance for growth, the size of the home crowd section | How much room to leave for change. Load, height and space that cost little now and a lot later |
| Fit-out | 10–15 years | Premium spaces, social and standing areas, concourses, F\&B, retail, flexible shell space | Which spaces must be reconfigurable, and the target cost of each change |
| Operating layer | 2–5 years | Connectivity, screens, apps, programming, creator access, content and screening rights, partners | Contract terms that allow change. Infrastructure sized for growth, especially upload |
Experienced operators already plan fit-out around a 15-year horizon rather than today's trends. The market will turn over several times inside that window, which is why the operating layer has to move faster.
My view
- The costly mistake is putting a fast-clock decision into a slow-clock layer. A tunnel club built around this year's trend, with fixed finishes and services, is a structure decision disguised as a fit-out decision.
- Renovating every five years is not realistic. The aim is spaces that can change cheaply between renovations.
- Most projects have a design team for the structure and an operator for the operating layer. The fit-out clock is where I most often see commercial input missing.
8. The commercial questions a feasibility brief must answer
These are the questions I would want answered before a design is fixed. None of them is a design question. Each one changes what the design has to allow.
- Who holds the fan relationship inside the building? Ticketing, Wi-Fi, apps and payments all collect data. The brief should say who owns it and who can use it.
- Who sells and owns the new inventory? Creator positions, social spaces, fan zones and shared-reality screenings are all sellable. The brief should say whether the venue, the tenant, the league or a partner sells each one, and who keeps the income.
- What filming, posting and creator rights will tenants need? Who grants them, in which spaces, at what times, and with whose sponsors in shot?
- How are sponsor conflicts resolved? Venue, team, league, event and broadcaster partners often overlap. The rules should be set before the naming-rights deal is signed.
- Who holds screening rights for experiences outside the bowl? Fan zones, watch parties and satellite venues need permissions from rights holders and broadcasters, and a clear split of income and cost.
- How much space must be reconfigurable, and at what cost per change? A target cost turns flexibility from a design aspiration into a number that can be tested.
- What premium mix still works in a downside year? And how large a general and home-fan section does the building need to protect its atmosphere?
- What will the next generation of tenants ask for? New leagues and touring events are a growing source of dates. Their needs for content rights, connectivity and fast changeovers should shape the brief, along with their ability to pay.
At Project B, I did venue work in Hangzhou, Singapore and Munich from the tenant's side. Most conversations came back to who owns the fan relationship. The venue usually wanted it to sit with its ticketing platform. What surprised me most was the cost of reconfiguring older venues, and in some cases that they could not be reconfigured at all.
9. What it means for each reader
| Reader | What changes | First move |
|---|---|---|
| Owners and developers | The building has to earn on more days and through more rooms than the bowl | Set the three clocks in the brief, with a target cost for each reconfigurable space |
| Operators | Rights, access and data terms decide what the building can sell | Write creator, filming and screening terms into tenant and event agreements now |
| Feasibility advisers | Fan behaviour and tenant needs belong in the demand case, alongside capacity and premium | Test the premium mix against a downside year and a protected general section |
| New leagues and event owners | Venues will compete for dates on connectivity, content rights and changeover speed | Ask for those terms in the venue deal, and plan the event for the screen as well as the seat |
| Investors | Value depends on how cheaply the asset adapts, as well as on today's occupancy | Ask what the next renovation will cost and what the brief did to reduce it |
10. The counter-case
The strongest case against this paper is that fan habits matter less to a venue's capital decisions than I suggest.
- Most of what social fans need is contracts and operations. Connectivity, filming rights, creator access and data terms can be added without moving concrete. Owners may reasonably say they already do Wi-Fi and content days.
- Premium and real estate drive the big money. The largest capital decisions follow premium demand and the land around the building. Those may shape the next generation of venues more than anything fans do with their phones.
- Flexibility can cost more than it saves. Space that needs heavy conversion, such as moving seating or retracting surfaces, has to be used often enough to pay for itself. Space that is simply easy to refit is a different proposition. The opposite risk is just as real. In my own venue work, some older buildings could not be reconfigured at any reasonable cost.
- Protecting the crowd has a price. A large affordable section earns less per seat than premium in a good year.
Does it change the recommendation? It sharpens it. The paper's main value is in the contract and operating layer, and in keeping fit-out space cheap to change. I would avoid prescribing new built forms. Where flexibility needs machinery, it should be tested against how often it will really be used.
What would change my view
- Evidence that venues with a strong general crowd do no better on premium pricing or renewal than venues without one.
- Evidence that designed-in flexibility is rarely used, or costs more to run than it earns.
- A sustained fall in in-venue posting and phone use.
11. Questions to ask now
- Which decisions in our next brief sit on the wrong clock? What are we fixing in structure or fit-out that will really need to change every few years?
- Is our network built for the moment fans send? What is our peak upload capacity on the biggest night, and who pays to grow it?
- Who owns what fans make and do in our building? If a creator, a tenant and a sponsor all want the same moment, whose rules apply?
- Would our premium still sell if the crowd were half as loud? And how much of the bowl are we protecting for the fans who make it loud?
I am always open to comparing notes with anyone working through these questions on a live project.